How to Split the Holidays Between Two Families: What Couples Therapists Recommend

Updated on:

A couple clinking wine glasses at a candlelit holiday dinner table

Splitting the holidays means deciding, as a couple, where you will spend Thanksgiving and the December holidays when two families would each like you at their table. It is a planning problem that does not go away after the first year of marriage: it shifts as parents age, siblings have kids and grown children start making plans of their own.

Most of the tension comes from loyalty, guilt and two sets of traditions that fall on the same day. Couples therapists say the fix starts with the two of you agreeing on a plan before either family weighs in.

Why splitting the holidays causes so much stress

Holiday stress in general is on the rise. In the American Psychiatric Association’s Healthy Minds Poll of 2,203 US adults in November 2025, 41% expected to feel more stressed than the year before, up from 28% the previous year, and 32% named difficult family dynamics as a worry. The same poll found that seeing family and friends was what people looked forward to most, at 61%. The people who make the season are often the people who make it complicated.

Splitting time is a big part of that. A 2024 survey of 1,007 partnered Americans by DatingNews.com found that half of couples divide the holidays between families, but only 38% manage to divide them evenly. One in three said they dread planning the split, one in four said they dread the trip to the in-laws, and 13% spend the holidays apart from their partner altogether.

There is a longer-term reason to get the in-law side right. Terri Orbuch, PhD, a researcher at the University of Michigan in Ann Arbor, followed 373 married couples for 26 years. As Advisory Board reported, couples were less likely to divorce when the husband felt close to his wife’s parents, and more likely to divorce when the wife felt close to her husband’s parents. Orbuch’s reading was about boundaries: wives tended to read in-law closeness as interference with their role as a wife and mother. The finding is a link, not proof of cause, but it is a good argument for agreeing on limits before anyone packs a bag.

Start with a private conversation, early

The first step is for the two of you to decide before either family is asked. Jordan A. Madison, a licensed clinical marriage and family therapist in Bethesda, Maryland, laid out a simple method on the Therapy for Black Girls podcast. Each partner writes down which parts of the holidays are non-negotiable and which are flexible. Then you compare lists and look for overlap. One of you may care most about Christmas morning, the other about a parent’s Christmas Eve dinner, and both can happen.

Madison’s advice on timing is to have that talk well before the holidays come up. A good working deadline is early October for Thanksgiving and early November for the December holidays, which also gives you time to book travel.

Drop the stopwatch, too. Moraya Seeger DeGeare, a marriage and family therapist in New York, told NPR’s Life Kit, in a story republished by the public radio station KAXE, that a fair split is not the same as equal hours. Ask instead when each of you actually enjoys time with family, and whether the date matters to anyone or just being together does.

A few prompts that keep the conversation useful:

  • Which one moment of the season would you be most upset to miss?
  • Does your family care about the date, or about seeing us at some point that week?
  • What is our travel budget for November and December combined?
  • How many nights away from home feels good, and how many feels like too many?

Five ways to split the holidays

Rachel Dack, a licensed clinical professional relationship counselor in Bethesda, Maryland, described the three classic options to WTOP News: see both families on the same day, rotate the holidays between sides, or spend a holiday as just the two of you. Here they are with two more that work well, plus who each one suits.

  • Alternate years. Thanksgiving and Christmas both go to one side this year and the other side next year. It is the simplest system to explain and the easiest to track. The downside is that each family goes a full year without you on the big days, which can sting for parents who are older or on their own.
  • Swap the holidays. Thanksgiving goes to one side and Christmas to the other, then you trade the following year. It suits couples whose families live far apart, since it means one big trip per holiday. It is harder when both families care most about the same holiday.
  • Split the day. Brunch with one side, dinner with the other. This is most practical when the families live within about an hour of each other, and it helps to cap each stop at a set time so nobody is waiting on dessert. Take turns on which side gets the main meal.
  • Host everyone. Bring both families to your home. It ends the travel debate and starts a tradition that belongs to you, though it puts the cooking and the peacekeeping on your shoulders. It works best once your home is the natural gathering point, for example after the grandchildren arrive.
  • Stay home or move the date. Spend the holiday as a couple and see each family on a different day. Madison suggests a Black Friday dinner or a New Year’s Eve get-together as stand-ins, and notes that siblings can take turns hosting the main day. She adds that being tired, the cost or simply not wanting to go is reason enough, and that relatives, grandparents especially, may push back. This suits couples who are worn out from travel or whose families are flexible about dates.

Whichever you pick, Dack’s warning applies: keeping score down to the minute does not work for anybody. Agree on the system, then stop counting.

Who tells each family, and how

Dack’s rule is that each partner tells their own parents. Families find it easy to cast the in-law as the reason they lost Christmas, so the news should come from their own child. She also suggests telling people early, being clear about where you will sleep and for how long, and acknowledging out loud that missing the holiday is hard for them.

DeGeare suggests presenting the plan as this year’s choice, not a permanent rule, which makes it easier to hear and easier to adjust later. Stephen Mitchell, PhD, a licensed marriage and family therapist with a doctorate in medical family therapy from Saint Louis University, made a related point with his wife and co-host, Erin Mitchell, on their podcast Couples Counseling for Parents: use “we” language, and keep it to one warm, short line that affirms your love and states the plan, not a list of reasons.

Some wording to borrow:

  • To your parents: “We’re spending Thanksgiving with Mark’s family this year, and we’ll be with you for Christmas. We know it’s a change, and we’re already looking forward to December with you.”
  • If they push back: “I hear that you’re disappointed. This is what works for us this year, and we’ll look at it again next year.”
  • If you’re staying home: “We’re keeping the day quiet this year. Can we come to you the Saturday after?”

Should you stay with the in-laws or book a hotel?

If the budget allows, book your own room. Karl Pillemer, PhD, a professor of human development at Cornell University in Ithaca, New York, and the author of Fault Lines, a book on family estrangement, told Cornell’s alumni magazine that he does not see why everyone feels they have to stay in the same house. If you can afford it, he said, a hotel or short-term rental is worth it as an escape hatch: somewhere to rest, talk privately and reset before the next meal.

Keep the visit shorter than you think you should. Jeremy Schumacher, a licensed marriage and family therapist in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, said on the podcast Your Therapist Needs Therapy that a couple of hours can be plenty for Thanksgiving dinner, and that his own family visits top out at about 24 hours. A practical middle ground for a long-distance trip is two or three nights, with one planned outing that gets everyone out of the house.

Money belongs in the conversation, too. Two trips in five weeks add up fast, so agree on one holiday travel budget that covers both families before booking. If one side is much farther away, a cheaper option (driving instead of flying, or visiting at a less busy time) is a neutral reason to change the plan that nobody has to take personally.

How to handle tricky moments during the visit

Schumacher describes a boundary as something you do, not something you make relatives do: leaving early, taking a walk or stepping into another room. He adds that a boundary usually has to be held more than once, and that it helps to plan your exits before you arrive.

Pillemer’s advice for the visit itself is to walk away from a conversation that keeps circling back to a sore topic, and to save heavy family discussions, such as a parent’s future care, for a calmer time than a holiday dinner.

A plan for the two of you:

  • Agree on a signal. A word or a look that means “I need a break,” so either of you can call a walk or a store run without explaining.
  • Back each other up. If your parent criticizes your partner, you answer, not your partner. “We’re happy with how we do it” ends most conversations.
  • Have one line ready for unwanted advice. DeGeare’s suggestion is a plain thank-you and nothing more, and her wider advice is to go slow and pick your battles.
  • Debrief afterward. On the drive home, each of you names one thing that worked and one thing to change next year.

Divorced parents, kids and long distances

Divorced parents can mean three or four households, not two. Pillemer suggests negotiating openly and expecting to make some concessions, for example to a recently widowed or divorced parent who might otherwise spend the holiday alone. Seeing that parent on a separate day, or inviting them to your home, can work better than adding another stop to the same afternoon.

If you have children from a previous relationship, a custody schedule may already decide part of the calendar. Some states publish default holiday schedules. Indiana’s Parenting Time Guidelines, for example, alternate Thanksgiving between parents in even and odd years and split winter break into halves that swap each year. Rules vary by state and by custody order, so check your own (this is general information, not legal advice). Plan the in-law split around the custody calendar, not the other way around.

Distance changes the math, too. AAA projected that 81.8 million Americans would travel 50 miles or more for Thanksgiving in 2025, with nearly 90% of them driving. INRIX traffic data in the same forecast flagged Tuesday and Wednesday afternoons before the holiday as the most congested times to leave, and mornings as the best. When one family is a short drive and the other is a flight, one option is to see the nearby family more often through the year and give the far-away family the bigger holiday, so the effort feels balanced even when the hours are not.

Starting traditions of your own

Traditions of your own give the season a fixed point that does not depend on whose house you are at. A review of 50 years of research led by psychologist Barbara H. Fiese, PhD, of Syracuse University separated family routines (tasks that get done) from rituals (events that carry meaning and say who a family is), and linked both with greater marital satisfaction. Thanksgiving and Christmas were among the rituals families mentioned most.

Madison calls blended traditions a remix of what each partner grew up with. A tree-trimming night, a holiday baking day or a drive to see the lights can be yours no matter whose house you sleep at on the 25th.

Pick a system as a couple, tell your own family yourself, and treat the plan as this year’s plan rather than forever. If you can only change one thing, book your own room if the budget allows: a door you can close makes the rest of the visit easier.

Leave a Comment

Flipboard