How to Ask for a Raise at Your Year-End Review: 7 Steps That Make a Yes More Likely

Two women talking at a sofa with a laptop open between them, one explaining a point with her hands

Many US employers hold performance reviews at the end of the year, which makes November and December a natural time to ask for a raise. The catch is timing: employers often draft their raise budgets months earlier, so the conversation goes best when it is planned rather than improvised in the review itself.

Asking is less common than it should be. In Payscale research covering more than 160,000 workers, only 37% said they had ever asked their current employer for a raise, yet 70% of those who asked came away with more money, either the full amount or part of it.

How big are raises right now?

Most US raises land in a narrow band of about 3% to 3.5%. Consulting firm Mercer found that 2026 merit raises averaged 3.1%, with total increases (merit plus promotions and adjustments) at 3.4%, both slightly below what employers had projected.

For 2027, the picture is close to flat. WTW’s salary budget survey of 1,650 US organizations puts the average 2027 budget at 3.4%, against 3.5% in 2026. Payscale’s Salary Budget Survey expects 3.5% for 2027 and also found fewer companies plan a flat, across-the-board raise: 32%, down from 36% in 2026.

Mercer notes that its averages include employees who get no raise at all. When fewer employers hand everyone the same percentage, the size of an individual raise depends more on performance and on how clearly the case is made. That makes a request in the 5% to 10% range an above-average ask. Ten percent is reasonable if you are paid below market or your job has grown. Above that, it is usually framed as a market adjustment or promotion rather than a merit raise.

When is the best time to ask for a raise?

Before the decision is made, not after. In Mercer’s summer survey, 87% of employers said their 2027 raise budgets were still preliminary, with a follow-up check planned for October, when numbers are closer to final. By a mid-November or December review, the overall pool is usually close to final, so the conversation is about your share of it.

That means the ideal window is a few weeks before your review, when your manager is still putting forward names and numbers. If your company gives raises on your work anniversary or on January 1, work back from that date instead.

Some moments carry more weight than others. Jamie Kohn, a senior director in the HR practice at research firm Gartner, told the Associated Press, in a story published by Fortune, that a request is stronger after you have taken on bigger responsibilities or are already working at the level of a promotion, and that recent performance reviews matter. Learning that you are paid well below colleagues with similar experience is another good reason to ask.

Avoid weeks when the company has announced layoffs, a hiring freeze or missed revenue targets. Raise budgets are rarely added to in those weeks, and the request can get lost.

How to ask for a raise in 7 steps

1. Find your market number

Start with what the job pays elsewhere, not with what you need. The free Occupational Employment and Wage Statistics database from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics lists pay for about 830 occupations, for the whole country, by state and by metro area, including the median and what lower and higher earners make.

Job ads are the second free source. At the time of writing, 14 states and Washington, D.C., including California, Colorado, Illinois, New York and Washington, require employers to post a pay range in job listings, according to HR data company Brightmine. Even if your state has no such law, listings for your role in those states show what employers are offering.

Salary sites such as Glassdoor, Payscale and Levels.fyi add self-reported numbers by company and level. Use all three sources to settle on two figures before the meeting: your target and the lowest raise you would accept.

2. Build a brag file

Managers rarely remember a full year of someone’s work, so bring the record yourself. Julia Evans, a software engineer and writer known for her programming zines, helped popularize the idea of a brag document: a running list of projects and their results, colleagues you helped or trained, behind-the-scenes fixes, and new skills. She updates hers every six months to a year and shares it with her manager, who can then argue her case to someone more senior.

For a raise, keep it to one page and lead with numbers: revenue brought in, money or hours saved, clients kept, a team you covered for. Add any duties you took on that were never reflected in your pay. Describe the work accurately, neither inflated nor played down.

3. Decide exactly what to ask for

Name a range, and make the bottom of it your real target. Columbia Business School professors Daniel Ames and Malia Mason found that a “bolstering range”, such as 8% to 10% when 8% is the goal, led to better outcomes than a single figure, and the person asking was seen as just as likable. Simply naming one bigger number did not help and led to deadlock almost twice as often.

Think about the whole package, too. Mandi Woodruff-Santos, a finance journalist, career coach and co-host of the Brown Ambition podcast, described pay as a “compensation cupcake” on Lemonada Media’s The Dough podcast: base salary, benefits such as 401(k) matching and stipends, equity, and one-time money such as bonuses or tuition help. Base salary matters most, because every future raise is calculated on it, but knowing the other layers gives you something to ask for if salary is capped.

Be clear with yourself whether this is a merit raise in your current role, a market adjustment because the role is underpaid, or a promotion with a new title. Each one is approved differently, and saying which one you want makes your manager’s job easier.

4. Book the meeting

Ask for a dedicated conversation rather than raising it at the end of a busy one-on-one. A short message works: “I’d like to set up 30 minutes before reviews to talk about my compensation for next year.” That gives your manager time to check the budget instead of answering on the spot.

Pick the hour carefully. Emily Epstein, CEO of Oakbay Consulting, who teaches negotiation at Harvard and UC Berkeley, told the AP to ask when your manager is well rested rather than at the end of a long day. In person or on video is better than email for the ask itself.

5. Rehearse out loud

Saying a number aloud is harder than writing it down. Mori Taheripour, who teaches negotiation at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, told NPR’s Life Kit to practice with a trusted person who can give honest feedback, and to open the real conversation with a moment of ordinary connection so it does not feel like a cold transaction.

Run through the likely replies as well: “It’s not in the budget,” “Let’s revisit next year” and “What number did you have in mind?” Having a calm answer ready for each keeps the meeting from ending at the first hurdle.

6. Make the ask

Keep it short and lead with your results. One simple structure: two or three accomplishments from your brag file, the market data, then the range. For example: “This year I took over the West Coast accounts and grew them by 12%. Similar roles in our area pay between $78,000 and $86,000. I’d like to discuss an increase of 8% to 10%.”

Then stop talking and let your manager respond. J.T. O’Donnell, CEO and head career coach at Work It Daily, recommends framing the request as an open question rather than a yes-or-no one, for example asking your manager to help you understand what it would take to earn a raise of a specific amount. That invites a plan instead of a flat no.

7. Get it in writing

Whatever is agreed, send a short follow-up email the same day: the amount or percentage, the date it takes effect, and anything you agreed to work on. A dated note protects you if your manager changes jobs before the raise goes through. When the effective date arrives, check your pay stub to confirm the new figure is there.

What to do if your manager says no

A no usually comes with a reason, and the reason shapes the next step. Payscale’s research found the most common reason given was budget, cited by 49% of people turned down, while 33% were given no reason at all and 9% were told they had asked outside the normal raise period. Ask which one applies to you.

Sam DeMase, a career expert at ZipRecruiter, told the AP to ask when the raise can be revisited and to get that timeframe in writing. Three or six months is a reasonable check-in, tied to specific goals you both agree on. Outside of that, once a year is the norm unless your role changes.

If cash is truly frozen, ask about other parts of the package: a one-time bonus, extra paid time off, a training budget, remote days or a better title. Readers of the workplace advice column Ask a Manager point out the trade-offs: one-off perks are often easier to win but do not raise your base pay, extra time off still costs the company money, and an inflated title can raise eyebrows in a future job search. A title should come with more pay, or at least a dated plan for it.

Only mention another job offer if you would take it. Woodruff-Santos made the same point on The Dough: a competing offer is leverage only when you are ready to walk away.

If you have been in the role for years or are at the top of your pay band

Long tenure can quietly work against pay. When salaries for new hires rise faster than raises for existing staff, people who have stayed put can end up earning less than colleagues who joined recently, a pattern known as salary compression. The fix is the same market research from step 1: compare your pay with current job postings for your role, not with what you earned when you started.

If your manager says you are already at the top of your pay band, ask when the band was last reviewed. A band set several years ago may simply be out of date, which makes the request a market adjustment rather than a merit raise. It is also fair to ask what a regrade or promotion to the next level would take, and by when.

If base pay is truly capped, a bonus, equity or a dated plan for the next level is the next best ask.

Should you ask for a raise or change jobs?

Changing jobs still pays more on average. The Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta’s Wage Growth Tracker put overall median wage growth at 3.9% in September 2026. In the same data, published by the St. Louis Fed, people who switched jobs saw 4.7% and people who stayed saw 3.4%, a gap of about 1.3 percentage points.

That gap is an average, not a promise, and leaving has its own costs. Before using a job search as your raise strategy, check when your 401(k) match vests, whether a year-end bonus is paid only to people still employed on a certain date, and what happens to unused paid time off. A strong raise conversation in December can be worth more than a new job that resets those clocks.

A practical middle path is to ask first, then look. If the answer is a firm no with no plan attached, you will know where you stand, and your market research is already done.

Common mistakes to avoid

  • Making it about personal costs. Rent, childcare and inflation are real, but a raise request lands better when it is about the value of the work and the market rate for it.
  • Waiting for the review itself. By then the number is often decided. Book the conversation a few weeks earlier.
  • Asking with no figure. “Whatever you think is fair” lets someone else set the number. Bring a range.
  • Giving an ultimatum you will not follow through on. It damages trust and can backfire if your manager calls it.
  • Accepting a new title with no money attached. Ask for the pay, or a dated plan for it, alongside the title.
  • Letting it drop after a no. Put the follow-up date in your calendar and come back with the goals met.

Most of the work happens before the meeting. A clear market number, a one-page record of results and a range that starts at your real target turn an awkward ask into a calm business discussion, and the earlier in the season it happens, the more room your manager has to say yes.

This article is general information, not financial or legal advice.

Leave a Comment

Flipboard