White elephant is the holiday gift exchange where the best present in the room rarely stays with the person who unwrapped it. Every guest brings one wrapped gift, and on each turn a player either opens something new or takes a gift someone else has already opened.
Almost every group plays by slightly different rules, and that is where the arguments start: how many times one gift can change hands, whether a player can grab it straight back, and who gets the final turn. Agree on those before anyone draws a number and the game stays fun.
The other half of a good game is the gifts. Only 38% of past players in one national survey said they went home with something they wanted, and the presents people fight over have a few things in common.
How does a white elephant gift exchange work?
The basic game is the same almost everywhere. Elfster, the gift exchange app, lays out the standard version like this:
- Everyone brings one wrapped gift within the agreed price limit, and the gifts go in one pile where all the players can see them.
- Players draw numbers to set the turn order.
- Player 1 opens a gift from the pile and shows it to the group.
- Every player after that has a choice: unwrap a new gift, or steal one that has already been opened.
- A player who loses a gift unwraps a new one right away.
- The game ends when every gift is open. Player 1, who never had a chance to steal, gets one last turn to swap with anyone.
Group size changes the game. With too few players there is little worth stealing, and with too many the middle drags. Americans surveyed in a 2019 Harris Poll for the shopping app Wish put the ideal group at 11 players on average.
How many times can a gift be stolen?
Settle the steal cap in writing. In Elfster’s version, a gift stolen three times is “frozen” and stays with whoever holds it. In the Harris Poll, 45% of players wanted a cap on steals, and the average cap they suggested was three.
A few other house rules keep the game moving:
- No immediate steal-back. In groups that let a player who lost a gift steal instead of opening one, that player cannot take the same gift straight back. Without this rule, two people can trade one gift back and forth forever.
- One steal per gift per turn. Elfster’s version lets a gift be stolen only once during any single turn, so a hot item cannot bounce around the circle before the next new gift is opened.
- A cap on players, not just gifts. Some groups lock out a player after three thefts instead of freezing the gift, one of the variations CBS News lists. The same piece warns that dropping limits altogether will likely slow the game down.
- Steal as you go. Some groups open every gift first and save the stealing for the end. Players dislike it: it was the rule people most wanted to get rid of in the Harris Poll, with 24% naming it.
Also decide whether a frozen gift can still be taken in Player 1’s final swap. In the version described in the Harris Poll release, Player 1 can swap only for a gift that is not frozen.
What is a good price limit for white elephant?
Keep it to about $25. In the Harris Poll, 64% of people said the ideal limit is $25 or less. For office exchanges, Harley Storrings, a labor and employment attorney, told the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) that $20 is a standard cap.
Elfster’s own suggestions climb with how well the group knows each other: $15 to $25 for students, $25 to $40 for the office, $30 to $50 for friends and $40 to $75 for family. Whatever the number, stick to it in both directions. Diane Gottsman, an etiquette expert and founder of The Protocol School of Texas, advises on her site setting a limit that lets as many people as possible take part, then not going far over or under it.
Is white elephant the same as a Yankee swap or Dirty Santa?
Yes. It is the same game with regional names. Mental Floss explains that Yankee swap is what New Englanders tend to call it, and Dirty Santa is the name common in the South, a nod to all the stealing.
Secret Santa is a different game. Each person draws a name and buys a gift for that one person, usually in secret. There is no pile and no stealing, and the giver can shop for someone they know. White elephant works better for a group where people do not know each other well, because nobody is buying for a particular person.
Why is it called white elephant?
The usual story is that kings of Siam, now Thailand, gave rare white elephants to courtiers they disliked. The animals were sacred, could not be put to work and cost a fortune to keep, so the gift was meant to ruin the person who received it.
It is a good story, and probably not true. Merriam-Webster presents it only as one explanation for the phrase. The etymology site Word Origins calls the royal gift practice a Western invention from the mid-1800s, since Thai rulers valued the animals far too highly to hand them out. Peter Jensen Brown, who researches word and pop-culture history on the Early Sports ‘n’ Pop-Culture History blog, found no early first-hand account of a king doing it, and traces the gift version of the idiom to an 1859 book.
The party itself is American. History.com reports that newspapers were promoting holiday swap parties in the 1890s and the “white elephant party” name was common by 1911. Mental Floss cites a 1907 Nebraska newspaper as the earliest known use of the phrase for a party.
What makes a gift worth stealing?
The Harris Poll found a gap between what people bring and what they want. Gag gifts were the most popular thing to bring, chosen by 27%. But household items topped the list of what people wanted to take home, at 24%, ahead of gag gifts at 18%.
The gap suggests a simple test. The gifts that change hands most tend to be:
- Useful to almost anyone. A gift that only suits one age, hobby or diet loses most of the room.
- A nicer version of an everyday thing. People rarely buy themselves the good olive oil or the heavy throw blanket, which is exactly why they will steal it.
- Good-looking once unwrapped. Everyone sees the gift at the moment it is opened, so a gift that looks good out of the box gets noticed.
- Easy to take home. Nobody wants to carry a lamp to the car.
Funny gifts can still work, as long as the joke comes with something people will use.
10 gifts worth stealing
These ideas fit a $25 to $50 limit and pass the test above. A few match the most wished-for items in Elfster’s analysis of public wishlists on its app, where a vegetable chopper, a travel makeup bag and a vintage-style mug set all made the top five. That list covers wishlists in general, not white elephant games, but it is a good guide to what people want.
- A heated throw or a heavy knit blanket. Useful in every house, and it looks generous unwrapped.
- A set of vintage-style mugs. Pair two with good coffee beans or a tin of hot chocolate.
- A vegetable chopper. It sounds dull until the first person who cooks a lot sees it.
- A nice bottle of olive oil with flaky sea salt. A small luxury most people will not buy for themselves.
- A travel makeup or toiletry bag. Works for anyone who travels, and a structured one looks expensive.
- A candle in a heavy glass or ceramic vessel. Choose a soft scent such as fir, fig or amber over anything sweet.
- A compact portable charger. It fits in a coat pocket for the trip home.
- A cocktail or mocktail kit. Shaker, jigger and a recipe card. Skip the alcohol at work.
- A good board or card game. Look for one that plays well with four or more people and takes under an hour.
- A gift card to a coffee shop or bookstore, wrapped inside a mug. The Emily Post Institute calls coffee shop and bookstore gift cards perennial favorites for a coworker you do not know well.
Ways to change up the game
A theme makes shopping easier and the gifts more fun to open. Ideas include “cozy,” “kitchen,” “self-care,” “something that starts with the letter B” or “under $20 and handmade.” Another twist is to keep every gift wrapped until the end, so players steal on the strength of the wrapping alone.
White elephant also works over video. The YouTube channel Score Marketplace walks through running a Zoom version, with each gift shown on a shared web page so remote players can see what they are choosing.
For anyone who wants to win, the YouTube channel Dr. Loveless Teaches Math uses one family’s white elephant rules to introduce fair division, a branch of math, with a section on house rules for stealing. A later number also means more opened gifts to choose from.
Is white elephant okay for an office party?
It is one of the better choices for work, because it is cheap and nobody shops for a specific coworker. The Emily Post Institute recommends a Yankee swap or grab bag for office groups, with funny gifts fine as long as nobody goes overboard.
A few rules keep it comfortable:
- Make it optional. SHRM’s guidance is that office gift exchanges should be opt-in, so nobody feels pushed to spend.
- Skip anything personal. SHRM advises against gifts that are romantic, religious, too personal or that make fun of anyone. Emily Post adds perfume to the list of personal items to avoid.
- Go easy on gag gifts. Gottsman suggests skipping them unless you know the recipient’s sense of humor well, and avoiding anything that could embarrass someone in front of coworkers.
- Put the rules in writing. Gottsman recommends sending them to everyone ahead of time, which also settles the price limit and the steal cap before the party.
The simplest way to a good white elephant is to settle three things before anyone draws a number: a price limit of about $25, a three-steal freeze and a final swap for Player 1. Then bring something you would want to steal yourself. In the Harris Poll, more players wanted household items than gag gifts.






