12 Things to Make With Vegetarian Thanksgiving Leftovers, and How Long Each One Keeps

Hands passing a wooden bowl of roasted potatoes and mushrooms across a holiday table set with linen napkins

A vegetarian Thanksgiving leaves behind the most useful leftovers of the year. Mashed potatoes, stuffing, roasted vegetables and cranberry sauce are building blocks, and with no turkey to work through, the whole fridge can go into waffles, pot pies and grilled cheese by the weekend.

The catch is the clock. Cooked leftovers keep three to four days in the fridge, which means anything from Thursday’s dinner should be eaten or frozen by Monday, a deadline FoodSafety.gov uses as its own reminder. Some sides also freeze far better than others, and a pumpkin pie and a pan of creamy gravy behave very differently in the freezer.

Stored well, those sides turn into stuffing waffles, potato cakes and soup, and a pecan pie can sit in the freezer until December.

How long do Thanksgiving leftovers keep?

Start with the two-hour rule. Cooked food should go into the fridge within two hours of coming off the stove or out of a warming dish, and within one hour if the room is above 90°F, according to the USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service. Bacteria grow fastest between 40°F and 140°F, and Manpreet Singh, a professor of food science at the University of Georgia, said on the university’s Cultivating Curiosity podcast that under ideal conditions they can double every 20 minutes.

Speed matters, so split big dishes into shallow containers no more than 4 inches deep, as University of Illinois Extension nutrition educator Lisa Peterson advises. For a deep casserole dish, Penn State Extension suggests standing it in a sink of cold water, swapping the water as it warms, and leaving lids off until the food has cooled. The same guide warns against cramming the fridge, because cold air has to move around the containers to keep everything at 40°F or below.

Once chilled, most vegetarian sides follow the three-to-four-day rule. A few last longer, and pie has its own timeline:

LeftoverFridgeFreezer
Mashed potatoes3 to 4 daysA few weeks for best flavor
Stuffing3 to 4 days4 to 6 months
Vegetable or mushroom gravy3 to 4 days4 to 6 months (flour-thickened)
Roasted vegetables, green beansUp to 5 days2 to 6 months
Vegetarian main (nut roast, lentil loaf)3 to 4 days2 to 6 months
Canned cranberry sauceUp to 2 weeksNot needed
Homemade cranberry relishUp to 7 daysNot needed
Pumpkin or pecan pieUp to 4 daysUp to 2 months

Those figures come from the USDA and state extension services: Penn State for stuffing, gravy and potatoes, Illinois for vegetables and cranberry sauce, NC State for the two-to-six-month freezer range, and University of Maine Extension educator Kathy Savoie for pie. Freezer times are about quality, not safety. Food held at 0°F stays safe well beyond those times, but flavor and texture fade, which is why NC State Extension recommends writing the date on every container. As a rule of thumb, eat the gravy and anything creamy first, and save the cranberry sauce and pie for last.

Which leftovers freeze well, and which don’t

Stuffing, flour-thickened gravy, roasted vegetables and most vegetarian mains freeze well. Pack them in portions you would eat in one sitting, in moisture-proof containers with a little room at the top for expansion, the method recommended by the National Center for Home Food Preservation.

Mashed potatoes are the tricky one. They hold up best when made with plenty of butter, cream cheese or sour cream, because the fat protects the texture, according to a separate Penn State Extension guide on freezing potatoes. Shape them into patties about half an inch thick, freeze them on a cookie sheet, then bag them, and plan to use them within a few weeks.

Plenty of other dishes are better eaten fresh. Oregon State University Extension lists the usual offenders: plain boiled or baked potatoes turn mealy, milk-based sauces and gravies can curdle, sour cream goes watery, and cheese or crumb toppings go soggy. That rules out freezing a creamy green bean casserole or a crumb-topped gratin as is. Freeze a sweet potato casserole before the marshmallows or pecan topping go on, then add the topping when you bake it.

Pie splits the experts. Kathy Savoie at Maine Extension says pumpkin and pecan pies both freeze for up to two months, and Iowa State Extension’s AnswerLine adds two rules: cool the pie completely before wrapping it in plastic and foil, and thaw it in the fridge for at least 12 hours so the crust doesn’t go wet. AnswerLine also suggests keeping it frozen no longer than a month for the best taste. The testers at America’s Test Kitchen found frozen pumpkin pie came back grainy with a soggy crust, while pecan pie froze well for two months. Freeze the pecan pie, and finish the pumpkin within four days.

How to reheat leftovers safely, and so they taste good

Reheat everything to 165°F, checked with a food thermometer, and bring gravy to a rolling boil, according to the USDA. The same guidance says frozen leftovers can go straight into the pan or oven without thawing, and food that was thawed in the fridge can safely go back in the freezer. NC State’s Safe Plates program adds that reheated leftovers should be eaten in one go, with anything left after that thrown out, so warm only what you’ll eat. In the microwave, cover the dish, stir or rotate it partway through and check the temperature in more than one spot.

For texture, skip the microwave where you can. Stuffing crisps up again spread thin on a sheet pan in a hot oven. For mashed potatoes, Food Network chef Jeff Mauro told The Takeout that he pours a layer of melted butter over the top, reheats them, then finishes them under the broiler for a browned top.

12 things to make with vegetarian Thanksgiving leftovers

1. Stuffing waffles

Smitten Kitchen creator Deb Perelman said on NPR’s All Things Considered that she likes pressing leftover stuffing into a waffle iron, where it picks up deep, crisp ridges and becomes a base for an egg. The ratio from Fountain Avenue Kitchen is one beaten egg per 2 cups of crumbled stuffing, pressed into a greased, preheated iron. Top with a fried egg and a spoonful of cranberry sauce.

2. Crispy mashed potato cakes

Cold mash is easier to shape than warm. Vegetarian blog Oh My Veggies mixes leftover mashed or sweet potatoes with corn or peas and fries them as fritters. Add an egg and a spoonful of flour if the mixture is loose, and fry in butter over medium heat so the outside browns before the middle is hot.

3. Polpettone, the Italian answer to shepherd’s pie

James Beard Award-winning journalist and cookbook author Kathy Gunst, resident chef on public radio’s Here & Now, binds leftover mash and vegetables with egg and Parmesan and bakes it in a breadcrumb-lined pan. It is a good home for small amounts of several sides at once.

4. A leftover frittata

Gunst’s other fix on the same show: fold stuffing, sweet potatoes or mash into beaten eggs and bake at 450°F for 10 to 12 minutes. Leftover roasted Brussels sprouts or green beans work here too.

5. Green bean and mushroom pot pie

Plant-based dietitian Sharon Palmer, RDN, known as The Plant-Powered Dietitian, pairs green bean and mushroom pot pies with mashed potatoes. To make one from leftovers, spread the mash over the vegetables in place of pastry and use leftover gravy as the sauce.

6. Sweet potato shepherd’s pie

Palmer’s roundup also includes a Southwest sweet potato shepherd’s pie. For a quick version, stir black beans, corn and a little chili powder into the leftover vegetables, spread the sweet potatoes over the top and bake until it bubbles at the edges.

7. Cranberry, pear and Brie grilled cheese

Karen Troughton, the vegetarian home cook behind Kitchen Treaty, includes a cranberry, pear and Brie grilled cheese in her leftovers roundup. Spread the cranberry sauce thin so the bread still crisps. Use leftover dinner rolls, split and pressed in the pan, if the bread ran out.

8. Cranberry sauce pancakes

Troughton’s roundup also has cranberry sauce pancakes with pecans; spoon the sauce onto the batter once it’s in the pan so it doesn’t burn. Leftover cranberry sauce also stands in for jam on toast or a topping for yogurt and oatmeal.

9. The vegetarian leftover sandwich

The turkey sandwich has a vegetarian equivalent. Oh My Veggies builds it on marinated tofu or tempeh. Slices of a cold nut roast or lentil loaf, seared in a skillet until crisp at the edges, work the same way, piled with stuffing, cranberry sauce and a little warm gravy for dipping.

10. A Thanksgiving grain bowl

Warm farro or wild rice, then add roasted vegetables, a scoop of stuffing and green beans. Thin the cranberry sauce with olive oil and vinegar for a dressing, and add toasted pecans or a soft-boiled egg for a full lunch.

11. Roasted vegetable soup

Leftover roasted squash, carrots or sweet potatoes blend into soup in minutes. Simmer them in vegetable broth with a little onion, purée until smooth and finish with a swirl of cream. When reheating it, bring it to a rolling boil, the USDA rule for soups and gravies.

12. A pie milkshake

Blend a slice of pumpkin or pecan pie, crust and all, with two scoops of vanilla ice cream and a splash of milk. It is the fastest way to finish a pie before its four days are up.

The simplest plan for the weekend: pack everything into shallow, dated containers before dessert is cleared, freeze the stuffing and pecan pie on Friday if they won’t be eaten by Monday, and start with the waffles.

Leave a Comment

Flipboard