A Make-Ahead Vegetarian Thanksgiving: What to Cook Each Day, From 2 Weeks Out to Thursday

Hands holding a pumpkin pie with leaf-shaped pastry cutouts on a green marble plate

A vegetarian Thanksgiving has one big advantage over the turkey version: nearly all of it can be cooked before Thursday. There is no bird to thaw, brine or roast all afternoon, so the oven stays free on the day, and the main dish can be built days ahead or even frozen.

Not every dish holds, though. Dressed greens wilt, crisp toppings go soft, and an apple pie assembled and left in the fridge overnight comes out with a soggy bottom crust. Food safety also matters more when every dish on the menu sits in the fridge for days and comes out to be reheated in batches.

Spread the cooking over two weeks and most of the meal is done by Wednesday night, leaving Thursday for letting the rolls rise, reheating dishes in the right order and dressing a salad.

What can you make ahead for Thanksgiving, and what can’t you?

Most of a vegetarian menu keeps well. These are the lead times for the usual dishes.

DishHow far aheadOn Thursday
Pie doughFridge up to 3 days, or frozenThaw overnight in the fridge before rolling
Shaped dinner rollsFrozen up to about 2 weeksThaw and rise 4 to 5 hours, then bake
Mushroom WellingtonFrozen unbaked up to 3 months, or assembled 24 hours aheadThaw overnight in the fridge, egg wash, bake at 400°F for 35 to 40 minutes
Stuffed squashFridge 3 to 4 days, or frozen up to 3 monthsReheat, then crisp the top
Lasagna or baked pastaFrozen 4 to 6 monthsThaw in the fridge, reheat to 165°F
Mashed potatoesFridge up to 3 daysBake at 350°F with warm half-and-half
GravyFreeze the stock, thicken close to servingBring to a rolling boil
StuffingPrep wet and dry parts separately, or freeze it mixed and unbakedMix and bake, or bake from frozen, until the center hits 165°F
Fruit pie, bakedRoom temperature up to 2 daysRewarm, tented, at 350°F
Pumpkin pie, bakedFridge 3 to 4 daysServe chilled or at cool room temperature
Green saladWash the greens the day beforeDress at the table

Two weeks out: fill the freezer

Start with the freezer, and check that it runs at 0°F or colder. At that temperature food stays safe indefinitely, and the storage times on the FoodSafety.gov cold storage chart are about flavor and texture, not safety.

Pie dough goes in first. Rossi Anastopoulo, an employee-owner at King Arthur Baking, suggests freezing dough until baking day, and passes on a tip from the company’s Baker’s Hotline: roll it straight into the pie plate and freeze the whole thing so it is ready to fill. Her colleague PJ Hamel, a longtime King Arthur writer, has a method for freezing dinner rolls before they are baked: mix the dough with cool liquid, shape the rolls without a first rise, freeze them on a tray until hard, then bag them. She recommends baking them within about two weeks and keeping them in a freezer that holds a steady temperature, not a self-defrosting one.

Pastry chef and cookbook author Claire Saffitz takes the same order in her start-to-finish Thanksgiving video for NYT Cooking: pie dough and stock come first, then pie fillings, with the Brussels sprouts and mashed potatoes coming last. For a vegetarian table, that stock is a vegetable or mushroom stock, which will become the gravy later.

Bags of fresh cranberries can go straight into the freezer too. Martha Zepp, a former program assistant with Penn State Extension, says they keep for up to 12 months and can be rinsed and cooked without thawing.

How far ahead can you make a vegetarian main?

A meat-free main saves the most time. Each of these centerpieces can be finished days or weeks early and needs the oven for under an hour on Thursday.

Mushroom Wellington. Sylvia Fountaine, the recipe developer behind Feasting at Home, makes the filling a day ahead, then wraps it in pastry without the egg wash. Wrapped tightly, it keeps in the fridge for up to 24 hours or in the freezer, unbaked, for up to three months. Thaw a frozen one overnight in the fridge, brush on the egg wash just before baking, and bake at 400°F for 35 to 40 minutes. She advises against reheating it in the microwave, which turns the pastry soggy.

Stuffed squash. Cadry Nelson, author of Living Vegan For Dummies and the creator of Cadry’s Kitchen, says stuffed acorn squash halves keep in the fridge for three to four days or in the freezer for up to three months. She reheats them in the microwave, then gives them 5 to 10 minutes in a 400°F air fryer to crisp the top.

Lasagna or a baked pasta. The easiest of the three to freeze. Clemson University’s Home and Garden Information Center puts lasagna at four to six months in the freezer. A butternut squash or mushroom lasagna made the weekend before only needs thawing in the fridge and reheating until the center reaches 165°F.

Monday and Tuesday: cranberry sauce, mashed potatoes and gravy

Cranberry sauce is one of the simplest things to make early, but it is better in the fridge than the freezer. Penn State Extension’s cranberry guide notes that a major cranberry company advises against freezing the cooked sauce, which may need stirring back together once thawed, and that the sauce sets best when it cools at room temperature before it is chilled.

Mashed potatoes can be made ahead too, despite their reputation. Averie Sunshine, the food blogger behind Averie Cooks, makes hers up to three days early. To reheat, she lets the dish stand for 15 to 30 minutes, pours half a cup of warmed half-and-half and 2 tablespoons of butter over the top without stirring, covers it with foil and bakes it at 350°F for 20 to 25 minutes before stirring. She skips cream cheese, which she finds can make the mash gummy.

Gluey mash usually starts at the mashing stage. Quartz, summarizing The Food Lab by food writer J. Kenji López-Alt, reports that the more the cooked potatoes are worked, the more starch they release: a ricer or food mill frees the least, a mixer more and a food processor the most. Russets also give a lighter mash than Yukon Golds.

Gravy is the one sauce to split in two. Clemson’s freezing guide notes that gravies thickened with wheat flour do not freeze well, so its advice is to freeze the broth and make the gravy close to serving. For a vegetarian gravy, that means the mushroom or vegetable stock comes out of the freezer on Tuesday, and the butter-and-flour thickening happens on Wednesday or Thursday.

Wednesday: pies, stuffing prep and thawing

Pies belong to the day before, and the type decides where they go once baked. Susie Craig, who presents Washington State University Extension’s Food Safety in a Minute podcast, says fruit pies can sit at room temperature for up to two days, while pumpkin and custard pies need to be refrigerated within two hours of baking and eaten within three to four days.

The one thing not to do is build an apple pie and leave it in the fridge unbaked. Annabelle Shippee, writing for King Arthur Baking with advice from its Baker’s Hotline, warns that the bottom crust goes soggy and suggests baking sliced apples within 24 hours. Pumpkin filling can be mixed the night before, and the crust can be rolled into its pan a day ahead and chilled. A baked fruit pie rewarms in about 15 minutes at 350°F, tented with foil.

Stuffing can be prepped but not assembled. The USDA Food Safety and Inspection Service says the dry and wet ingredients can be made ahead and chilled separately, as long as they are combined just before baking, with the oven heated to 325°F or higher. Mixed but uncooked stuffing should never sit in the fridge, but the same page says it can be frozen in a shallow container and baked from frozen until it reaches 165°F. Otherwise, cube and dry the bread, cook the onions and celery, and keep the broth and eggs apart until Thursday.

Move frozen dishes into the fridge on Tuesday or Wednesday, and give a full lasagna the longer of the two. The USDA’s leftovers guide notes that fridge thawing is the slowest method but keeps food safe the whole time, and that frozen soups and casseroles can go straight into the oven or onto the stove without thawing, given extra time.

Thursday: an oven plan for the day

With no bird in the oven, Thursday is a matter of sequencing: group dishes by temperature and work back from the time dinner is served.

  1. Five hours before dinner: take the frozen rolls out to thaw and rise, covered, at a cool room temperature. PJ Hamel allows four to five hours.
  2. About 75 minutes before: bake the Wellington at 400°F, turning it around halfway, or put a thawed lasagna in to heat through.
  3. About an hour before: mix and bake the stuffing alongside it, until the center reaches 165°F on a food thermometer.
  4. About 40 minutes before: when the main comes out to rest, lower the oven to 350°F. The mashed potatoes (out of the fridge 15 to 30 minutes earlier) and the rolls bake together, and the stuffing stays in until its center reads 165°F.
  5. At the table: dress the salad at the last minute. While plates are cleared, rewarm the fruit pie at 350°F for about 15 minutes, tented with foil.

A slow cooker frees up a burner for the gravy, but only for holding. E.H. Hoyle, PhD, a food safety specialist at Clemson University, advises against reheating food in a slow cooker. Heat the mash or the stuffing on the stove or in the microwave until it is steaming and at 165°F, then move it into a slow cooker that has been preheated and holds at 140°F or higher.

How to store and reheat Thanksgiving dishes safely

Cooking days ahead only works if the fridge is cold enough: 40°F or below. The USDA’s leftovers guidance covers the rest:

  • Cool fast. Divide big batches into shallow containers so they chill quickly. Hot food can go straight into the fridge.
  • Watch the clock. Cooked food should be refrigerated within two hours, or within one hour if the room is above 90°F. That includes the hour a dish sits on the counter “coming to room temperature” before reheating.
  • Reheat to 165°F. Check with a food thermometer. Gravy and soup should come to a rolling boil.
  • Leftovers keep three to four days. After that, freeze them or throw them out.

The two-hour rule is worth remembering on the day too. Dishes left on the table through a long dinner should go back in the fridge once the plates are cleared.

What should you not make ahead?

Chefs interviewed by Food & Wine, in a story syndicated on Yahoo, put fresh greens, cornbread and baked rolls on their make-on-the-day list, because the greens wilt and the breads dry out. Freezing the roll dough unbaked gets around that: the rolls still come out of the oven fresh on Thursday.

Some foods also lose quality in the freezer. Clemson’s guide lists mayonnaise, custards and cream fillings, gelatin salads, cheese and hard-cooked egg whites, and notes that milk sauces sometimes curdle. A creamy pie, a deviled egg platter or a cream sauce for the green beans is a fridge job for the day before, not a freezer job for two weeks out.

If only one thing gets done early, make it the main. A Wellington or lasagna in the freezer turns Thursday into a day of reheating, and leaves room to add a couple of vegetarian sides that disappear first and a pitcher of batch cocktails made the day before.

Leave a Comment

Flipboard